Sunday, March 3, 2013

Reflection Questions

Directions:


1. Spend 5 -10 composing a thoughtful response (at least 3 or 4 sentences) to each question.
2. When finished, read your classmates’ responses and add insightful comments or ask challenging questions.
3. Respond to your classmates’ comments and questions.
 

1.       Socrates said, “The unexamined life is not worth living” (Plato’s Republic 38a). What do you think this quote means? How might it apply to your life in general? How might it apply to our class so far?

2.       What might some of the benefits of composing a reflective essay be for the writer? What are some benefits for peer reviewers? What might the benefits be for the class’s instructor?

3.       What kinds of reflective ideas might be valuable to the writer, peer readers, and the instructor? What kinds of comments or statements might function as filler with little or no substance?

4.       You are free to write your reflective piece in any form or genre you find interesting and productive. It can be a letter to the instructor, a letter to a family member or friend, a personal essay, a dialogue, a short story, a poem etc. What might be some of the benefits and drawbacks of these forms in meeting your reflection goals? Can you think of any other forms that might be interesting to try?

27 comments:

  1. 1. I believe this quote is about if you do not conduct further examination and question reality, then there would be no point in living in a world without question. It is applicable to the class for the students must question why it is mandatory to take this class.
    2. The benefits of compsing a reflective essay would be to assess yourself and your literary text(s). The benefits of a peer review are to ask for another person's opinion and help create an understanding for others about your topic. Peer review isn't always so pure. The benefits of the instructor would be to see if he/she is doing their job right.
    3. Reflective thoughts that might be valuable to a person would be to expand your research and be more open minded to another's view point on the subject.
    4. I would write poetry for my reflective essay because a poem can speak to people in different ways. I feel as if it was just a plain written paper then it would not let people think so hard about what I am writing about or expand their imagination.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ben: regarding question 1, why do you think all UM students are required to take WRIT 101?

      Delete
  2. 1. I think so oftent information really goes in one ear and out the other. When we watch a couple of hours of TV, most of us would have a difficult time describing what we just saw in much detail. I think (and research backs this up) to make experiences and knowledge stick in the long-term memory, we have to think about them. I hope this class isn't just busy-work that you have to trudge through as a general requirement; instead, I hope that some of the ideas and skills related to writing can transfer and help enrichen your lives later in your college and throughout your lives. To do this, reflection is essential.

    2. I think for the writer, reflection helps to articulate strengths and weaknesses, making them concrete and allowing celebration and a goal for improvement. For the peer readers, reading about others' struggles and triumphs may help her/him feel less alone. Writing can be such a solitary process, and it's easy to feel like you're the only one banging your head against the wall. Seeing other people's reflections will prove you're not. For me, the instructor, I can gain a better understanding of which points writers already know they should work on (so I can try to be more sensitive in my comments) and which areas might be blind spots that I can bring to writers' attention.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 3. As with any type of writing, unsupported and overly generalized claims -- for example, "I learned so much" or "I've suffered so much" without any kind of supporting evidence are very fluffy and unsubstantial.

    Don't be afraid to quote, paraphrase, and summurize yourself! For example, "When I wrote ... on page .. of my PAE, I was trying to..." Pointing to specific places in your writing is very helpful to both you and me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. 1. This quote "The Unexamined life is not worth living," is very simple and straight forward. Socrates is simply saying that if you dont carefully examine your life, and what you are doing with it, you will end up doing nothing. A person should have goals, and something that they want to acomplish, other than getting up and going to work every day. If we all lived a life of placensy the world would be a very sad place to live.

    2. A reflective essay is a good self evaluation. It helps the author review if they got the paper to go in the direction they wanted, if they met the goals and guideline set for them, and help them understand what they gained from their own writing. The reviews from the peers helped in the critical sense. These reviews helped me see if my paper had good points, interesting sentences, and was easy to understand. The instructor of the class can learn a lot about a writer from the reviews a person writes. If a student puts forth effort in their reviews of their peers work, it is clear that the person cares about the class, and is willing to put forth effort in making their writing better.

    3. Some useful ideas of review that would help all parties involved would be concerning the thought process behind the writing, if the person is pleased with the paper they wrote, if the subject followed the intended line, or if the paper took a twist from the information that the author didnt expect. Filler information would probably be something about grammar, sentance structure, delaying the paper till the last minute, and things like this that really arent the maing goal of a review. If the author is giving themselves a decient review worth their own time, i doubt that the grammar and sentance structure in their paper was that terrible, and probably doesnt deserve mention in the review paper.

    4. There are some interesting ways to document a review paper. Origionally i thought that it would be a traditional reply essay. These tend to be incredibly boring, and painful to read in my opinion. They hold very little interest for me. A question and answer seems like it would be more interesting. This would probably fall under "Dialogue," and i think i could hold a lot of personal ideas that an essay would miss out on, just because it is more difficult to answer questions in an essay format. I think the dialogue will be easy to have meet the goals because when an entire idea has been discussed, you just simply transfer to the next topic with a new question and not worry about transition sentences, new paragraphs and what not. It is more focused on the idea of simple review. A poem sounds very different to me. I have never been much of a poem guy, and writing a response poem to a personal academic essay just seems absurd to me, but i would really like to see someone try it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Re Question 3, I think you're right on about how process is interesting and things like mechanics and procrastination stories are kind of filler.

      Delete
  5. 1."The unexamined life is not worth living" is an awesome quote and concept. It means that you shouldn't float through life, but actually explore it and test it. This applies to our class because we are exploring our writing and not just doing the assignments just to get them done.
    2.Composing a reflective essay is very beneficial for the writer because it makes them look at their work in great depth. The peer reviews also help because it helps the writer receive a different point of view on the their writing, and helpful feedback. The instructor is able to see the person's writing ability and how the other students react to that person's paper by the peer review.
    3.Valuable reflective ideas are ones that are helpful to the writer. That may be helping with grammar, the flow of the paper, or clarity of the idea. Fillers would be encouraging notes. They aren't really helping the paper out, but they are important.
    4.There are some benefits of different forms of reflection pieces. I think the main one is that they aren't as formal, so there isn't so much pressure. That could also be a drawback. Because it isn't a formal paper, grammar, and other technicalities, may not be as nice as it would be on a formal paper. I cannot think of any other forms that may be interesting to try at the moment.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Why do we live in a place where the media makes people who read books as nerds or not-so-cool individuals? Reading literature expands your mind as well as your intelligence. It also helps you depict the author's own thoughts to induce your own imaginataion. Television and movies do the exact opposite and allow for no creativity to broaden.
    Soft tv.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 4. Last semester, most students wrote kind of standard personal essays. A few wrote letters to me, but one of the most intersting ones was a dialogue in which the student interviewed himself. The strength was that the questions and answers were direct in getting to the point while avoiding fluffy overgeneralized writing, and sometimes, the interviewer asked, "Can you please be more specific?" or "Can you give me an example?" It worked really well for that student, but as Hillary said, "Different strokes for different folks."

    ReplyDelete
  8. 1. I think that quote is essentially saying that if you don't reflect and examine your life, you are wasting it. It seems similar to the more modern idea that you can't know where you are going if you don't know where you are coming from. In reference to this class, it seems to be illustrating that we are supposed to reflect on our work.
    2. Composing a reflective essay will allow the writer to analyze and understand where their strengths and weaknesses fall. The peer reviewers can learn different styles of working from their partner rather than focusing on only their style and system. The instructor can see if the students are putting forth effort and what difficulties they are running across.
    3. I think the most beneficial reflective ideas would be describing the process, what worked and didn't work, and what the writer would have done differently. This allows the writer to not only pinpoint problem areas, but makes the writer find a solution. The peer reviewer may be able to adopt those solutions or suggest a different solution. Filler statements would be statements that have nothing to do with reflecting. I think that listing problems without solutions would have little substance or value.
    4. I think that I will probably use the personal essay. A big drawback is that I will have to have a plan on how to make it organized but I did them during public speaking after every speech. A free write might be better to get everything on paper but sometimes those are hard for anybody but the writer to understand.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1. I believe the quote to mean that if one doesn't look into their own lives and find meaning or direction for themselves, then their life becomes meaningless. As a college student I am frequently asked, "What are you going to school for?" and for a little while I had no idea. I was just going to school for the sake of doing it, but after taking a few classes and finding what I like to do I decided on a path and am currently following it. So farI believe the quote can be applied to our class easily. When we were first looking for our topics there was not much direction and the idea of writing a multiple page essay seemed beyond us, but after finding something that intrigued us we were able to write many pages on our subject.

    2. A reflective essay lets you delve deeper into your own habits and abilities as a writer and do a self critique. Peer reviewers can then get an idea from the writer to find where they believe they struggled or came across strongly so they can give better feedback. An instructor benefits from a refective essay by letting the student better find out about themselves without strict guidance and also gets to watch the writer develop a style and personality of their own.

    3.Some reflective ideas that can be valuable to a writer are ones that make you think about your work, why you wrote something the way you did, and how you can improve in the future to get a point across more clearly.

    4. Personally I think any of these forms of reflecting can be positive, and anything that gets you thinking about your writing, even if it gets a bit off topic, then makes it worth while. Personally I prefer a dialoge or letter when I refect on my own writing as it comes a bit more naturaly to me. I also enjoy freewriting a lot. I tend to start off on topic, divert for a paragraph or two, but then tie it all together in the middle and finish strongly with a better idea of where I have strengths and what areas that I need to work on.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. About your answer to number three. I like the idea, but I am always too close to my own writing to be able to tell someone why i wrote a paragraph the way I did or to realy tell where I need work. I like to ask people with more experience them me to look at my pappers and tell me were they think I could use some work.

      Delete
  10. 1. To me personally Socrates quote is trying to tell us that if something is not worth examining it isn’t worth anything. He wants to tell us that if something isn’t examined that there is no point to it as it has no value to anybody but the “life” or person. To apply this too my life I would have to strive to do things and have thoughts and ideas that are worth other people examining and looking into. To apply it to the class I would want to write papers and works that other people want to examine and learn from. To make it worth examining it would have to be beneficial to more people than just me and therefor in a way it would be “a life worth living”.

    2. There are many benefits in composing a reflective essay for me as a writer. Writing any piece of work would be pointless and not worthwhile if you as a writer could not reflect on the piece and learn from it to become not only a better writer but a better individual and learn about yourself. The same is true for a peer reviewer. It is beneficial in more than just one way when you can read peers paper and see maybe a different mindset and spin on an idea or topic. There is a lot to learn about a peer and who they are or how their mind works based on reading there paper which can help you as a peer become a better writer. The class instructor can benefit in all the same ways as the peer but he can also learn to teach better and help a student better by seeing flaws in papers and helping fix them so they don’t happen again

    3. Reflective ideas always need to be constructive but honest. Being too fluffy and not being honest with a person in the reflection phase will not benefit them at all and the writer is not going to learn how to become a better writer and maybe where some of the holes in their essay are weaknesses in writing style are. On the other hand being overly negative and destructive can lower their confidence as a writer and only make the issues they have worse. We need to try and be constructive with our reflections and try and help improve the writing instead of tear it down while still being honest.

    4. Writing in a more creative way like a letter to the instructor or a poem can have many benefits and drawbacks. Being creative with the writing helps many people, including me express themselves better and helps process thoughts in an exciting and fun way instead of a boring essay that you are forced to do any really won’t get anything out of it. On the other hand a creative essay could be distracting where the main focus would be to write elegantly and make every word count and be perfect where you should be trying to learn from the past essay instead of trying to construct a perfect new one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Re: 3: I agree, constructive honestly is essential. There is nothing less useful than either saying "I'm an awesome writer and there's nothing I need to improve" or "I'm a terrible writer and I'll never improve."

      Delete
    2. I agree with your point about trying to write an elegant new essay instead of focusing on learning from the writing you have already done.

      Delete
  11. 1. I'm not really sure what this quote means. I am pretty sure I find it false though. Who is this man to say any life at all is not worth living. Every person leads with their own set of values and morales. I believe it is up to each one of us to personally figure out what our own life is worth and how we shall go about living it. It is not for me to worry about what someone else is doing with theirs. I have a hard time trying to apply a quote to anything that I do not find true.

    2. I think some benefits of a reflective essay could be to show the writing process that the person went through. The person writing it can see if they took any different steps than usual when writing this essay as they would have on a different assignment. It also give the reader a chance to see more styles than they would if not for the reflection. Maybe they can pick up better or even just different writing habbits than they already have.

    3. Seeing the process of how the person went about writing their paper. I think you could gain a little insight from any comment or statements that anyone throws out to you. There doesnt have to be a bad insight that someone can give to you. You can take any insight and pull what you need to from it to try to better your writing.

    4. I think it would be interesting to have the person who is reading your piece interview you about your reflection. Then you can get a better idea of what theyre looking for in your reflection. If youre questioning yourself you may not get as in depth of a response as the person may be looking for.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think that this quote from Socrates means that livning life without putting thought and your own self into what you do is not a life worth living. Everything you do should be done by you and in your own way to make it yours. In my life everything is more worth doing if I come up with it myself and put my own work into it and not the work of someone else. This quote applies to our class because we should all be doing our own work and writing about things that we are interested in and have an effect on all our lives.
    The benefits of composing a reflective essay are that you can look back on your paper and see what you are doing wrong and what you are doing right ve the chance to understand your writing a little better.The benefits of peer reviewers are that you can see what other people in the class are doing and benefit from both their good ideas and their mistakes. The benefit for the class instructor is being able to see where everyone in the class is at in terms of writing and is able to see if the students know what is wrong.
    The kinds of reflective ideas that would be beneficial are ideas like what could be done better and how could the writer improve off of what they have just accomplished. The peer reader could see what the writer has done well and possibly work off of those ideas and the mistakes of the writer to better his or hers own writing. The kinds of comments that would be more filler would be like small grammar mistakes I feel like the reflective essay should be more about content and research then mechanical errors.
    The freedom to select any form of writing style is an advantage more then a detriment. That freedom allows us to better form our ideas in a way that is better suited to us and teaches us how to show our ideas in the best way possible through different forms of writing. I think a short story or a dialogue would be the most interesgting way to write the paper because you have a lot of freedom and you can add different elements like some form of comedy to make your essay more readable.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 1. He is saying that if your experients are not learned from then there is no reason to have those experiences. I think it applies to my life in that I try to examine my experiences, especially my mistakes, to try to learn from them. In the class we examine not only our own work but also that of our classmates so that we may learn from them aswell.
    2. Writing a reflective essay allows the writer to look back and see where they could have done better and to see what they did well and actually write it down. Peer reviewers of reflective essays have the opportunity to see what the author has learned and can see if it could apply to their own writing. The instructor is able to use the reflective essays to see where the students feel they need work and where they have improved on their own.
    3. Some helpful comments in a reflective essay would be like, I should have spent a little more time researching my topic or editing my paper. An example of a "filler" comment would be, overall I think I did very well. Another "filler" comment would be something like, I have learned so much, without actually have a point or example of what you learned.
    4. One drawback, I think, to using a more artistic form such as a poem or a story, is that I think I would focus more on making it creative or making it sound right. A dialogue would make it easier to transition from one point to the next.

    ReplyDelete
  14. 1. It is saying live your life to the fullest. Don't be afraid to take risks and don't just accept things for what they are. Go out and be an individual thinker with goals and purpose in your life. If you don't your life could end up being wasted.

    2. In writing a reflective essay it gives you the opportunity to reanalyze the writing that you have done and learn from it. The reader can learn from what the writer is saying and apply it to their own writing. It gives the instructor insite into the writer's process and what they were thinking when they wrote their essay.

    3. I think talking about what worked well and what didn't work so well is very helpful in reflective essays. Writing it down makes it easier to notice these things and apply it to later essays.

    4. All of these forms of writing can be good for writing a reflective essay. I usually write personal essays for my reflective pieces because I think it is easiest to clearly state my ideas. However,other forms of writing like poetry could allow the writer to express their ideas in a more creative and interesting way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like your take on the quote! Very inspirational and encouraging.

      Delete
  15. 1. I think what Socrates is saying here is that you must evaluate yourself and examine your progress through life in order to grow. If you reflect on your growth, see that you have not changed or improved yourself, and don't do anything about it, your life is not worth living. It is important in not only your writing, but in every aspect of life to evaluate yourself and your decisions and your improvement in order to grow and learn. It might apply to this class so far, because really, if you don't evaluate your own writing, how do you every expect to improve?

    2. One benefit of composing a reflective essay that stands out to me most in particular is that you can see, almost through someone else's eyes, your whole process of writing. You can compare that process with how you think the process of writing should actually work and see if the two "match up". I think a lot of us have higher standards for work than we actually perform so it is interesting to compare the two. I think for peer reviewers, it is beneficial to see how other go about the writing process. There might be a more efficent and effective route than you even realize. It also might be beneficial to an instructor because they can see exactly how students go about writing an essay (and if they are having any trouble spots) and find ways to help them improve their process.

    3. I think the kinds of reflective ideas that might be valuable to a writer, peer reader, and instructor would include over-arching themes of writing. I also think that the little mechanics like "using ebsco" and "writing 3 introductory paragraphs" would be good things to include because they are specific examples of how to go about the writing process. It might give others ideas, like "Oh! Maybe I should use the sources journal as I go along and not so much just filling it in at the end because I had to. That really seemed to be beneficial for her!". Some things that I think are "filler" are things that everyone knows how to do like "I used size 12 Times New Roman font and used military style date..." etc. Things like that will make your essay boring to read because everyone already does those things without being told to most of the time.

    4. I think a letter to the instructor or to a friend might be a very effective form of writing to get your point across. That format, I think, would be interesting because it's almost like you would be instructing the teacher how to do something (i.e. write a personal academic essay) rather than the other way around; kind of like flipping the classroom. Something might really jump out the instructor like "Oh my, she should not be doing that." or "Wow! I never even thought to do such a thing. Another interesting format would be a dialogue! For example, asking questions to yourself and then answering them like "So how did you keep track of all of your sources?" or "What was the most time consuming part of the PAE writing process?" Questions like these could really stimulate a lot of good ideas and an informative reflective essay.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. re 3: great point on including research methods. I think this often gets overlooked but can be really helpful to peers.

      Delete
  16. 1. Maybe "The unexamined life is not worth living" is like "Those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it". A life without reflection means blindly making the same mistakes over and over agian. That's just a waste of time.

    2. Sometimes writing things down forces you to view your subject in a different angle (and since the subject is you) that could be very enlightening. Peer reviewers and the instructor might find personal essays less boring to read and more relevant to their own lives. (or maybe not..)

    3. Honest, specific ideas that stay on topic are going to be valuable. Generic statements that could fit any situation or sound like they came from a self-help book are probably not going to be helpful.

    4. The structure of the writing can make it easier to get an idea out. For example, a short story uses full sentences compared to a poem where the words are condensed. Sometimes that limitation forces you to get right to the heart of the subject. Haiku?

    ReplyDelete
  17. “The unexamined life is not worth living”
    To me this quote is saying that we are supposed to interact with people and observe each other. In my life I have a goal to positively affect others. So this correlates real well with what I believe this quote to be saying. If I don’t examine others how will I know what I can do to try and help them? In class we use this blog to comment and examine other peoples comments. If we couldn’t examine others work, give them tips and let them examine our work, what good would we be to each other in a classroom setting.

    Composing a reflective essay can be very helpful for a person to look back at the work they have completed and the process they went through and decide what they could do better next time. Having a peer review can really help you see were you are and maybe were you need to be. It can also be useful to help out one of your peers as well. The class instructor can give you advise and help from a graduate perspective and give you tips that they wished they would have had.

    Writing down the process you took while completing your paper could be very helpful to yourself, peers and instructor. This can kind of give them an insight to your thoughts. Some comments or statements that could be less help full would be things like what you thought about the font you were using.

    The benefits of using so many different forms of writing your reflective goals is that your creativity is not hindered by the form because you got to pick it. It also might give the reader a better insight to your paper. A draw back is that with so many different forms it might be hard to follow.

    ReplyDelete
  18. 1.
    This quote means to me that if you don't examine your life you wont know what your accomplishemnts have been or were you stand in the world. I have not lived long and have not achieved and great accomplishments so I am not sure how this quote applys to my life in general. Perhaps for me it means I need to examine what I have done so far and what I still need to do in order to get were I want to be before I die. Since the quote is talking about our lives as a broad topic with out narrowing anything down, I can't imagine how this appys to our class when I will be spending such a small amount of my life taking it.

    2.
    A benefit that I can see a reflective essay having to my writing to showing me what I need to work on and what areas I am already pretty good at. I have almost never found any benefit in peer reviewers because thay are all so busy with their own pappers and ideas that they skimm over somone elses papper and write down comments that have no accademic value. Or, they don't care to review a papper and give some lame comment like "this is good" or "I like it". Assuming people took the time to write a review comment with substance, the benefits for the instructor would be reading a more refined final paper and having to make only minor corrections.

    3.
    I have no idea. I don't think any reflective writing is of any benefit to peers because a reflective piece is a personal paper for the writer and have no importance to any other student. The instructor may benefit in knowing what each student feels they are bad at, but I have found that most of the time individuals don't know exactly what they are bad at so all instructors should take a reflection piece with a grain of salt. The filler comments or statements are easy to see. They are the unneeded, general, or "everybody knows", info. that is added in at odd places or used as bad transition sentences.

    4.
    I think the denefits and drawbacks to any form of reflective essay realy depends on the person who is writing it. For example, I suck at composing poems and would be shooting myself in the foot if I chose to write a poem for my reflective piece. On the other hand, Shell Silverstien whould write a great reflective poem. I would write a bad short story, Steven Spielburg would write an excelent one, or at least an intersting one.

    ReplyDelete
  19. 1) I think this questions means, not to live the life you don't know about. This questions applys to me because i am living the only life i have known about and that is playing basketball. I feel like it applys to our writing class by writing about topics you 'somewhat' know about.

    2) Some of the benefits of writing a reflective essay for the writer would being able to judge your own work. Having a weakness in your paper and being able to pick it out. The benefits for a peer reviewer would be, being able to see common mistakes and that could strengthen their own paper. I think seeing what the classes overall weakness is,so the intructor can work on it with the class would be the intructors benefit.

    3) Some reflective ideas would be talking about the structure of the paper, organization, grammar, and each individuals weakness. Statements or comments that could function as a filler would be anything without supporting evidence.

    4) Being able to write to somebody is easier than just writing to write. It has a purpose and a personal voice. I can't think of any other forms to write a reflective essay.

    ReplyDelete
  20. 1. Socrates quote to me means that you have to take a step back and look at your life. When you step back and examine, you can find reason for living. With the reasons found while examining, you can complete them. The time and effort need to complete the tasks makes life worth living.
    2. Composing a reflective essay can benefit a writer because they can acknowledge their work in a different manner. Instead of just seeing their piece as “shitty”. For peer reviewers, they can see the writing through the author’s point of view. They can experience how the author felt about their work and it could also help clear up any confusion. The benefits would be the same for the instructor as peer reviewers.
    3. Some reflective ideas would be talking about the structure of your essay, the way you approached the topic, what you wanted to accomplish with you writing and the quality your writing as a whole. Fillers would be comments and statements with no or little supporting evidence.
    4. A draw back to being able to write our reflective piece in any form or genre would be that it wouldn’t be composed as properly as a formal essay. This would also be a benefit for some because they write better with no restrictions or format.

    ReplyDelete