Friday, March 8, 2013

Argument & Civil Discourse

Step 1:

Please write a blog post on your assigned question. When you finish writing, read and comment on other students' posts.

Questions:

1. What were your experiences writing arguments in high school?

2. What are some practical uses for making arguments?

3. Do you enjoy engaging in arguments (either formal or informal)? Why?

4. Do you feel like you’re a persuasive person, a persuadable person, both, neither? Use specific examples in your explanation.

Step 2:

Let's watch a clip from the Daily Show. As you watch, think about (maybe take notes on) this question: What are some things writers should and shouldn't do in making effective, fair, and constructive arguments?

http://showyou.com/thedailyshow/h%3AUXrigRa1Gb2q8KMp


Step 3:

Read the following editorial. As you read, note points you like and dislike. Is it realistic or idealistic? How does his definition of argument differ from the chart on argument we began class with? How might you reframe issues from your (or others') "rants" more positively following his advcice?

5 tips for creating civil discourse in an era of polarization | Opinion | The Seattle Times

Op-ed invention resources:

 http://missoulian.com/news/opinion/

http://www.montanakaimin.com/opinion/

http://missoulanews.bigskypress.com

mountainwestnews.org

high country news: http://www.hcn.org/wotr






19 comments:

  1. 1. I don't have a lot of experience writing arguments in high school. I only wrote one and it was in sophomore year. I honestly couldn't tell you what it was on, or really how to write one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 2. I feel like some practical uses for making arguments is to kind of put your opinion out there and see what others think of it. To see if people agree or disagree with your thinking habits. Another use is to be to make a point. If there is an issue and youre definitely on one side of the fence, to try to get others to think about the issue the way you do. One thing I dont really like about arguments is sometimes people are just too hard headed to see things any other way and there has to be this sense of Im right and youre wrong. Even if both people have strong valid arguments, theres still this sense of a winner and loser. I think arguments are more about expanding your mind and should focus less on the who won kind of aspect about it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly! Making arguments and expressing your opinion a rational or unique way is part of the democratic process.

      Delete
  3. 2. What are some practical uses for making arguments?

    There are several practical uses for making arguments. During problem solving sessions you may have to argue (or debate) a point so that others can see your position clearly and you can move forward. Arguments can be designed to persuade someone who may be on the other side or on the fence about an issue. You can also make arguments to broaden somebodies perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I graduated high school seven years ago. I am fairly sure I had to write arguments but I really don't recall what they were. It generally was something about a book that I had to read but I am fairly sure we didn't argue anything much outside of literature. I am pretty sure I was very non-confrontational back then. I doubt I did much arguing.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Julia, you might have had more experience writing argumentsthan you realize. Your teachers might not have explicitly used the word, but any paper with a thesis is an argument -- not all arguments are on politics

    ReplyDelete
  6. 4. I feel like I can be a semi-persuasive person if the topic that I am trying to persuade the person of is really important to me. If it isnt I tend to just get frustrated and not care enough to really put in the time and effort it takes to persuade a person of an idea. I like to think that I am also pretty open minded. I guess it really depends on the topic but for example with our PAE and writing about hemp I learned a lot of information that helped me change my perspective of the plant.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 3) I really don’t really like confrontation so arguing is not one of my favorite things. Informal arguments can occasionally be fun when both people are not radical and when it is not personal. When arguments get personal it takes any enjoyment straight out! I may engage in some formal arguments every now and then just because I have to for class. These arguments are more knowledge base and are more nerve racking because you normally have an audience. So if you are not making a good argument you just look really stupid and that is embarrassing. I would like to skip that hold process and never involve myself in such activities!

    ReplyDelete
  8. 3. I don't particularly enjoy engaging in arguments. The main reason is that it almost always becomes personal in some way. Most people tend to stick to their side of an argument even when they have to point and have lost the argument. I feel like I am not very confrontational. I don't ussually get worked up over peoples opinions. Although I don't particularly care for them they do offer a good opportunity to learn something new or to see a mew point of view.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 4. I'm not that sure I am a very persuasive person. I hate confrontation and I hate fighting and in general am just pretty passive. So if an argument were to come about, I usually just end up letting it go. I would say that I am pretty persuadable though, (not to be confused with niave of course). I would like to think that I am pretty open-minded and love to hear other people's opinions and perspectives; it's really interesting to me to hear how other people think. When it comes to something that I really believe in and am passionate about however, I do have the ability to stand my ground. There are certain topics like the public education system and personal morals that I don't think there can be much persuading done. I love to hear others' opinions on these topicsbut mostly I think I am pretty firm about what I belive.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1. I prefered writing argumentitive essays over other types of essays. This is not to say that I actually liked writing them but they were easier to do. Because I had to take a side it narrowed my focus and made it easier for me to stay on track. I had an English teacher that would make us to write a convincing opinion that we personally disagreed with. It forced me to stand on the other side of the fence. I think it made my arguments stronger because I couldn't just say I believe this because.. instead I had to really disect each idea and cross examine them for flaws.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Question 3.
    I like arguing when I'm debating an oppinion becase no one will ever win and it usually stays friendly. No one will win because we are arguing about an oppinion and oppinions, by nature are neithor wrong or right, they are simply an expresstion of what someone thinks about a topic. However, if it is touchy topic and the person I am arguing with takes it personally, then its not fun at all because feelings get hurt and people get angry. As long as the mood of the argument stays light and fluffy, it can be a lot of fun.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 2. Arguments can be very useful, but also very destructive. Sometimes it is difficult to determine when it is appropriate to argue. In my opinion there are lots of different kinds of arguments. Simply disagreeing on a topic isnt necessarily an argument. It is when you exchange each persons views on the subject and then defend your ideas or opinions with facts that you have obtained previously. This is a propper form of arguement that has little to do with emotional stimulus. Emotion can be a powerful weapon in an argument but if your entire argument is based off emotion, it is likely that your opinions are fairly weak. Emotion is powerful when it is the second driving force. The facts and hard evidence need to be at the forefront of the argument, while emotion can be the driving force behind that. I believe this is the best way to clearly present a well formed opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great point, Cody! Choosing a topic that matters to you is essential.

    ReplyDelete
  14. We did a lot of writing involving picking a side on an argument and writing about it in high school. . We would often be given a controversial topic, and be told to pick a side and write a persuasive paper on it. We would all write our five paragraph essays with an introduction, three supporting paragraphs, and a conclusion just like we did with every other essay in high school. I think this is a good form for an essay but I wish they would have given us more freedom to write in whatever form worked best with our thoughts. Then we would come back and have an argument with our teacher over our topic.

    ReplyDelete
  15. 1. In high school, argument writings come up a lot. Usually they come up on essay questions for tests in english or history and you have to pick a side and defend it. Somethimes, however, the teacher told us which side to argue for. One time in particular my teacher had my argue one side, but i strongly disagreed with the subjct matter. While writing, though, i figured some things out and it actually ended up changing my mind on the topic.

    ReplyDelete
  16. 4. I can be persuative if I am passionate about my argument and have a lot of knowledge to back it up. If it is an argument that I'm not quite sure of my own stance then I tend be be less persuasive and I can be drawn to one side or another if someone knows more on the subject. Though once I have made up my mind I tend to be quite stubborn and don't back down.

    ReplyDelete
  17. One reason to have your arguments heard is to raise public awareness and promote your opinion on issues that are important to you. For example, Pebble Mine is very controversial in Alaska and I have a very strong opinion about it. If I or others who share my opinion were to write about this issue, we would hope that our arguments would persuade others to agree and support our cause. Another is to have your opinion, whatever it may be, heard and recognized by peers. If you make a Facebook post or an opinion column, it is likely that someone will respond, whether with a comment or a letter to the editor, and they will either back up your opinion or present another argument that will offer you a new perspective on the issue, whether you choose to acknowledge it or not.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Question 4
    Am I a persuasive person? I would have to say that I indeed am a persuasive person. But I can only be persuaive when I'm passionate about the topic and have advanced knowledge of the topic. I can bring forth the effort to expose you to both the pros and cons of the topic but still explain why someone should accept it. Yes, they say you should pick a side and argue it, but how can someone make a choice when they are not presented all the information? I present cons because when you presents the pros the examples will seem that much greater.

    ReplyDelete