Thursday, March 28, 2013

Op-ed unit wrap-up

Here's our poem of the day:




Driving Montana
The day is a woman who loves you. Open.
Deer drink close to the road and magpies
spray from your car. Miles from any town
your radio comes in strong, unlikely
Mozart from Belgrade rock and roll
from Butte. Whatever the next number
you want to hear it. Never has your Buick
found this forward a gear. Even
the tuna salad in Reedpoint is good.

Towns arrive ahead of imagined schedule
Absorakee at one. Or arrive so late--
Silesia at nine--you recreate the day.
Where did you stop along the road
and have fun? Was there a runaway horse?
Did you park at that house, the one
alone in a void of grain, white with green
trim and red fence, where you know you lived
once? You remembered the ringing creek,
the soft brown forms of far off bison.
You must have stayed hours, then drove on.
In the motel you know you’d never seen it before.

Tomorrow will open again, the sky wide
as the mouth of a wild girl, friable
clouds you lose yourself to. You are lost
in miles of land without people, without
one fear of being found, in the dash
of rabbits, soar of antelope, swirl
merge and clatter of streams.

--Richard Hugo

Our topic for writing on the blog:

Whether or not you grew up in Montana, you're all here now, and Montana is a beautiful place to be. I'd like you to spend about 15 minutes describing a specific and interesting place (or places) you've visited or lived in Montana. It can be a place you're very familiar with, somewhere you've been just once, or a description of the first impression you had when you came to the Treasure State.

Reflective Writing:

Again, I'd like you to reflect on your process of writing the Op-ed paper and do a little bit of final self-analysis. Here are some questions to consider:

What are some insights you gained related to our work on invention, research writing and revision?

In which of these areas did you struggle the most?

If you could go back in time, what would you do differently?

Which part of your essay do you feel most proud of?

Are there any places that still feel a little weak?

Did you enjoy this genre (op-ed) in comparison to the PAE?

Do you feel like your writing has improved at all since the beginning of the semester?

Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Letters to the Editor 2

First, we'll compare op-eds and letters to the editor in terms of form and content.


Here are a couple of good examples:

http://missoulian.com/news/opinion/mailbag/olsen-s-opinion-defending-greed-of-energy-producers-lacked-honesty/article_74171704-93eb-11e2-9807-0019bb2963f4.html

http://missoulian.com/news/opinion/mailbag/mcps-superintendent-apostle-seems-clueless-or-liar/article_2c025f5c-7201-11e2-905a-001a4bcf887a.html

http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/mailbag/golden-pen-award-passenger-rail-service-important-to-montana/article_a514b729-f94a-59aa-a583-39a0ac31bf15.html

http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/mailbag/raise-awareness-of-violence-against-indian-women/article_f1c46089-c97c-500d-a512-9cbdff2250ae.html

Also, here's a site that might help clarify and offer some useful advice:


http://newsroom.depaul.edu/facultyresources/OPEDTips/index.html


Finally, I would like you to select one of your classmate's op-ed papers that you feel compelled to respond to in the genre of a letter to the editor. You may choose to agree, offer encouragement, expand on an idea, disagree with partially or disagree completely. It's okay to have a strong opinion, but try to stay respectful. 


When you're finished, please email a copy to me as well as the op-ed's author.




Monday, March 25, 2013

Letters to the Editor

Explore the following locations and browse through the letters to the editor.


As you do, think about how the purpose and form compare and contrast with the Op-ed genre.


http://missoulian.com/news/opinion/mailbag/

http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/mailbag/

http://mtstandard.com/news/opinion/mailbag/

http://www.nytimes.com/top/opinion/editorialsandoped/letters/

http://www.sfgate.com/columns/letterstoeditor/









Homework for Wednesday:

1. Revise your op-ed, taking your partner's advice into account.

2. Submit your best draft to me via email (eric.lynn@umontana.edu) by midnight Tuesday.

Friday, March 15, 2013

3/15 -- Time to decide on a topic...

Activity 1.


Write a post on the blog giving your topic, arguable question, and/or working thesis.

Add a few sentences on what background information you already have, information you hope to find, how you might use logos, pathos, and ethos appeals, and how you might approach the topic in a way that promotes civil discourse.


Activity 2.

After finishing your post, comment on your classmates' posts, focusing your questions and comments on the interest, focus, disagreement, information, & question. (CW 270-271)



Activity 3.

Choose one of the following articles and read it paying particular attention to the writer's use of voice

Missoula cell-phone-while driving ban:
http://missoulanews.bigskypress.com/missoula/slow-lane/Content?oid=1690399

Mixing religion and politics:
http://www.creators.com/opinion/molly-ivins/molly-ivins-june-29.html

The badmitton scandal in the Olympics:
http://www.miamiherald.com/2012/08/02/2925122/dave-barry-first-olympic-scandal.html

Group Discussion Questions:

What do you notice about the writer's use of voice? How is it different than academic writing?

Is this voice effective? In what ways?

People tend to skim op-eds and most newspaper content. Does the use of voice force readers to slow down and read more carefully? If so, include examples?

Would you consider using humor or other stylistic elements to make your voice unique and memorable in your own op-ed? Why or why not?

 

Homework for Monday:

Read CW 273-280

Complete your op-ed sketch. (See CW 273-274 for required elements and an example.)

Print out 2 copies and bring them to class.

 

 

 

 

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Homework for Friday:

Read: "Is humiliation an ethically appropriate response to plagiarism" (CW 262-265) & answer questions 1-4.

Review "Common Logical Fallacies" and "Features of the Form" (CW 251-252, 254-256)

Decide your arguable question for the op-ed and continue researching independently.

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Invention for the Op-Ed


Here's our reading for the day:

"To be read. To be heard. To be seen. I want to be read, I want to be heard. I don’t need to be seen. To write requires an ego, a belief that what you say matters. Writing also requires an aching curiosity leading you to discover, uncover, what is gnawing at your bones. Words have a weight to them. How you choose to present them and to whom is a matter of style and choice. But in a voiced community, we all flourish."
* Terry Tempest Williams – When Women Were Birds: Fifty-Four Variations on Voice – 2010 – Ch. 13

 
What is the writer saying?

Do you agree with her?

How might such thoughts apply to our class generally and the Op-Ed assignment more specifically?

Friday, March 8, 2013

Argument & Civil Discourse

Step 1:

Please write a blog post on your assigned question. When you finish writing, read and comment on other students' posts.

Questions:

1. What were your experiences writing arguments in high school?

2. What are some practical uses for making arguments?

3. Do you enjoy engaging in arguments (either formal or informal)? Why?

4. Do you feel like you’re a persuasive person, a persuadable person, both, neither? Use specific examples in your explanation.

Step 2:

Let's watch a clip from the Daily Show. As you watch, think about (maybe take notes on) this question: What are some things writers should and shouldn't do in making effective, fair, and constructive arguments?

http://showyou.com/thedailyshow/h%3AUXrigRa1Gb2q8KMp


Step 3:

Read the following editorial. As you read, note points you like and dislike. Is it realistic or idealistic? How does his definition of argument differ from the chart on argument we began class with? How might you reframe issues from your (or others') "rants" more positively following his advcice?

5 tips for creating civil discourse in an era of polarization | Opinion | The Seattle Times

Op-ed invention resources:

 http://missoulian.com/news/opinion/

http://www.montanakaimin.com/opinion/

http://missoulanews.bigskypress.com

mountainwestnews.org

high country news: http://www.hcn.org/wotr






Monday, March 4, 2013

1. Discuss what gave you the most difficulties.
2. What was the most memorable moments and successful parts of your writing.
3. Discuss where the paper took you, and in which direction your thought process was traveling.
4. Filter out overly negative and overly optimistic generalizations.
5. Have quotes from your own writing and what your efforts and thoughts were about that certian quote.
6. State what you learned from the paper. Examine the work, research, and process to see what you gained from the essay.
7. Include what outside influences helped with or hindered your writing.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Reflection Questions

Directions:


1. Spend 5 -10 composing a thoughtful response (at least 3 or 4 sentences) to each question.
2. When finished, read your classmates’ responses and add insightful comments or ask challenging questions.
3. Respond to your classmates’ comments and questions.
 

1.       Socrates said, “The unexamined life is not worth living” (Plato’s Republic 38a). What do you think this quote means? How might it apply to your life in general? How might it apply to our class so far?

2.       What might some of the benefits of composing a reflective essay be for the writer? What are some benefits for peer reviewers? What might the benefits be for the class’s instructor?

3.       What kinds of reflective ideas might be valuable to the writer, peer readers, and the instructor? What kinds of comments or statements might function as filler with little or no substance?

4.       You are free to write your reflective piece in any form or genre you find interesting and productive. It can be a letter to the instructor, a letter to a family member or friend, a personal essay, a dialogue, a short story, a poem etc. What might be some of the benefits and drawbacks of these forms in meeting your reflection goals? Can you think of any other forms that might be interesting to try?