Here's our reading for the day:
"To be read. To be heard. To be seen. I want to be read, I
want to be heard. I don’t need to be seen. To write requires an ego, a belief
that what you say matters. Writing also requires an aching curiosity leading
you to discover, uncover, what is gnawing at your bones. Words have a weight to
them. How you choose to present them and to whom is a matter of style and
choice. But in a voiced community, we all flourish."
* Terry Tempest Williams – When
Women Were Birds: Fifty-Four Variations on Voice – 2010 – Ch. 13
What is the writer saying?
Do you agree with her?
How might such thoughts apply to our class generally and the Op-Ed
assignment more specifically?
The line that really drives this thought process home is, "But in a voiced community, we all flourish." To me this line describes the fact that we need to question what is going on in our society. If we dont question what is happening around us, we will never really understand what we believe. Believing something is wrong or right helps us to improve our society, but without this criticalness we would lose sense of purpose as a community.
ReplyDeleteExactly, and I might add that beyond questioning, we should also feel inclined to join the conversation.
DeleteBallenger also writes, "Aguing is a civic duty. It is an essential activity in any democratic culture and a major element of academic discourse" (240). I feel like the PAE helps students prepare for research-based assignments to come later in their studies, but the op-ed, where we engage in community issues and make our voices heard, is a practice that can be carried throughout life. It's impossible to care about every issue, but it's essential to care about a few and to translate that passive care into an active expression of voice.
ReplyDeleteI think the writer is saying that writing about your beliefs is important to a community. In general, I agree with her. Sharing ideas and beliefs is an important part of social change as well as sustaining things that the community values. The Op-Ed assignment is a way to do what the writer is talking about. It is a way to state an opinion.
ReplyDeleteI think the author is trying to say that writing is a good way to express your feelings. Writing helps take something that might be hard to say, feel or otherwise get out and express it in a way that makes sense.
ReplyDeleteThat’s just my thought though. I really have no idea what this chick is trying to say. Seems she wants to be vague and contorted and to force the reader to read between the lines.
I agree with the fact she presented that how you choose to present your voice and to whom is a matter of style and choice. I feel that it is impossible to voice your opinion to everybody so carefully choosing who you present your positions to can kind of help you more with presenting your opinions. And by choosing your own audience you can see better who you think would agree with your psitions and pass on your thoughts and even their own, creating a cycle of personal knowlege I guess. It can create a huge cycle and present your opinions through others and theirs through others and so on.
ReplyDeleteOr that he presented. Sorry I dont know if its a man or woman
DeleteShe is saying that writing can help you understand yourself better and in a community context, help everyone understand each other better. I think she is probably right if that is why people are writing. I feel like that isn't always so. Writing isn't always done to further self understanding and even if it was, it has to be read that way. Readers can twist writing to suit their purposes and meet their own agendas.
ReplyDeleteThe writer is saying that she thinks her opinions are important and should matter to other people and that she wants other people to hear her. It is not important to her if people see her, but rather she would like to be read and understood through her writing.
ReplyDeleteI don't completelly agree. I think there is something to be said about delivery, body language, and being personable to deliver your thoughts. I personally think that I am a stronger speaker than a writer and that if I had an actual conversation with someone, it might be easier for me to get my point across through speaking.
Her thoughts might apply to an op-ed assignment more specifically because it is mostly an opinion based peice. Writing could be an effective way to express how you feel about an issue.
She is saying that in order to write, you have an ego. You have to know that what you have to say is important. I think she is correct when she says that. If you don't think what you have to say is important, why say it? I think it applies more so to the op-ed than the rest of the class so far in that it is your own specific opinion about something and youir opinion matters to you. So if you are going to share it, you want it to matter to the people you are sharing it with.
ReplyDeleteThe writer is saying that voicing your opinions through writing allows everyones voice to be heard. I agree for the most part, but a lot of times writing doesnt completely get the point across. Also, not everyone likes to write. Generally, for our class, this makes sense since we are a group of writers and everyone's voice can be heard through writing.
ReplyDeleteShe is saying to me that writing is a form of self expression, to form opinions or state facts, and to place these words on a paper takes an amount of confidence in oneself to genuinely write what you feel is right on the paper. I do agree with her completely. Writing is a place where we can say what we believe and we need to have confidence in ourselves to write that down. These thoughts apply to our class because in our Op-Eds we will be writing primarily our own opinions and we have to have confidence in what we belive in and be able to write it down on the page.
ReplyDeleteThe writer is trying to explain that being heard is far more important and worthwhile than being seen. She proposes that to write you have to believe that you have something worth saying and that deep down you have a story to tell and something important to share with people. I agree that people who are passionate about what they are writing usually write stronger and more influential pieces that usually are going to have a bigger impact on people. I believe that words have power and using them does take an ego if you want to have any impact on anybody. For our op-Ed I think it speaks a lot to what topic we chose. If we are going to pick a topic that we aren’t honestly passionate about then nobody is going to care what we write. I think for us to write a great op-ed or even be successful in this class we have to have what we are writing about "gnawing at your bones".
ReplyDeleteThe writer is saying that as a writer you feel as if what you are writing is worth reading. That your opinions count, and is worth hearing. I agree with her. I feel that it is your opinion that is trying to be displayed and how you present it is you choice. But, you can't just present a normal opinion. You mus feel passionate about your views, and help the reader understand your passion about the topic. Without that, the community may not listen. This applies to the Op-Ed assignment because the whole point is to get your opinion out there on a topic that may be a little controversial.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the writer is saying that writing is something that we do to have our opinion heard bym many without actually meeting and talking to them. She does not mind if no one actually sees her or talks to her, but she uses writing to communicate with the world. I agree with her to an extent. I agree that writing is a way to reach many people with your words, and that it can be done anonymously. Also, when she talks about words having weight to them and that you can choose how you sound by style and choice of words, I agree with her again. Words can have incredible, world-changing power to them, and how you use them is as important as anything. What I do not agree with is when she says that she does not need to be seen. I agree that I do not want everyone to see me, but for the people I know, who are most likely to read my writing, I am ok with being seen. This is relevant to our class and assignment because she is telling us how words can influence people and portray things the way you want them portrayed, even when you are not seen
ReplyDeleteI think the writer is trying to say that our writing will have the best impact on people if we sound confident and knowledgable about the topic(s) we are discussing.
ReplyDeleteI don't agree with the statment 'To write requires and ego' because I have found that writers with an ego tend to ramble about their topic if they know what they are talking about or not. Also, when reading those articles, it is very obviouse the writers are full of them selves and that make me want to stop reading.
I think the part that will apply to our class assignment the most is the last part: 'How you choose to present them and whom is a matter of style and choice. But in a voiced community, we all flourish'. In our class, as long as we can write in a style that works for those we are expecting to read our papers, our assignments will be succesfull. That and it dosen't matter what we choose to write about or if anyone els is interested because we are allowed to speak our minds and be heard.
I think the writer is saying that hearing others opinions and voices is better and more important than seeing them. A community that focuses on voice and opinion rather than looks will succeed.
ReplyDeleteI agree that a community with people listens to each other is more beneficial than a community focused on looks.
These thoughts apply to the Op-Ed assignment because in our class were are acting like a small community and we are hearing each other rather than turning in individual assignments and just seeing each other.
I believe that Terry is saying that she wants her opinion to be heard and acknowledged and that as writers we should share that same drive. We should search for something that we care and want to learn more about through writing. I do agree with what Terry writes. I like when she says, "Words have a weight to them. How you choose to present them and to whom is a matter of style and choice. But in a voiced community, we all flourish." It applies to our class fairly well as we may not want to share what we write with everyone, but may seek out a specefic person to read it.
ReplyDeleteI feel that Terry Tempest Williams is saying we don't have to speak to be heard. Writing is a way to express what we feel, understand and think. We can chose an audience and write for them. I personally agree with the artist. I think writing is a great way to be heard!
ReplyDeleteThe author is stating that you dont need to be seen to be heard, but to be understood requires individuality. As an individual the style and choice of how they present their voice varies. With the differences, a person can understand others and can come to an understanding. I would have to agree with Terry and what she is saying and trying to express.
ReplyDelete