Friday, March 15, 2013

3/15 -- Time to decide on a topic...

Activity 1.


Write a post on the blog giving your topic, arguable question, and/or working thesis.

Add a few sentences on what background information you already have, information you hope to find, how you might use logos, pathos, and ethos appeals, and how you might approach the topic in a way that promotes civil discourse.


Activity 2.

After finishing your post, comment on your classmates' posts, focusing your questions and comments on the interest, focus, disagreement, information, & question. (CW 270-271)



Activity 3.

Choose one of the following articles and read it paying particular attention to the writer's use of voice

Missoula cell-phone-while driving ban:
http://missoulanews.bigskypress.com/missoula/slow-lane/Content?oid=1690399

Mixing religion and politics:
http://www.creators.com/opinion/molly-ivins/molly-ivins-june-29.html

The badmitton scandal in the Olympics:
http://www.miamiherald.com/2012/08/02/2925122/dave-barry-first-olympic-scandal.html

Group Discussion Questions:

What do you notice about the writer's use of voice? How is it different than academic writing?

Is this voice effective? In what ways?

People tend to skim op-eds and most newspaper content. Does the use of voice force readers to slow down and read more carefully? If so, include examples?

Would you consider using humor or other stylistic elements to make your voice unique and memorable in your own op-ed? Why or why not?

 

Homework for Monday:

Read CW 273-280

Complete your op-ed sketch. (See CW 273-274 for required elements and an example.)

Print out 2 copies and bring them to class.

 

 

 

 

25 comments:

  1. I think my topic is going to be about the animosity between BMX riders and skateboarders. My arguable question is why arent bikes allowed and why they should be allowed in public skateparks? This is an issue I have dealt with my whole life as I like to ride BMX bikes. I have found this situation to be excluding, violent(sometimes, not many), and just plain stupid. I think that everybody should just be able to get along and have fun shredding.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This topic is a little bit light, but that's okay. We don't all have to write about heavy political stuff. It works since you have a strong personal connection. Don't be afraid to have fun with it using humorous overstatement and interviews with skaters and BMXers.

      Delete
  2. My topic is about the breweries in Montana and how the Tavern Association is making it impossible for the new breweries to succeed. I want to argue on the fact that the Tavern Association is only thinking about their own income and not thinking about Montana’s economy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think this is really interesting, and im always interested in our state and national economy. However I have no background information on the Tavern Association or what their purpose is. How do you connect to this topic? Do you have some ties to the brewery industry or are you simply an economist that wants to see gains in our system?

      Delete
    2. I think "making it impossible for breweries to succeed" might be a little bit of an exaggeration -- making it harder for them to flourish might be more accurate. This could be a really interesting topic if you do enough research (and legwork)to find out what the laws and ordinances are, who's responsible for them, and what their effects are and could be. Also, you might want to focus specifically on one case. Are you thinking about the original Kettlehouse?

      Delete
  3. I am going to do this paper on physician assisted suicide. I think it is interesting topic because people don't like to talk about suicide in general let alone the idea of legally getting a lethal prescription from a doctor. I'm not sure how to incorporate ethos other than I work in the medical field. I'm pretty sure I can make a strong pathos appeal. Logos may be difficult, but other countries have had this legal for some time now. Oregon also has legalized it. I am hoping to find reviews from states that have legalized this. I ideally would like to find information for and against. I haven't found much information other than why it is currently in a confusing light in Montana. There was a case in the Montana Supreme court that essentially legalized physician assisted suicide, but did not clarify anything. I think that was Baxter vs. State of Montana.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's great that you're already looking at court cases. I agree that arguments on both sides tend to rely heavily on pathos. That doesn't necessarily make these arguments invalid. I think the fact that you're in the medical field is enough ethos. Quotes from physicians or even philosophers help build ethos as well. I've seen some people bring up medical cost saving and sparing families from bankruptcy as a logos argument, but it comes off as a little bit cold-hearted.I think as long as you're clear about the law and the policies hospitals have adopted in Montana, you should be fine drawing comparisons from other states and countries.

      Delete
  4. My topic is bullying in elementry school. Everybody has been bullied at some point in their life, and we can all agree that it isn't a fun experience. I want to discuss ideas about how to deter bullying with younger children. I'm not going to assume that it is a perfect world and there will never be bullying, and I believe that some people actually become a much stronger person from being bullied, but I know that it is often much more detrimental that it is helpful. I want to look at some studies about the bullies themselves. I want to understand why they act the way they do. Personally I think it is because of a weak home life. I'm not entirely sure how a school system can improve the home life of a young, troubled child but I will try and generate or reinforce some ideas that could be beneficial.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This sounds like a great topic. I really like your idea about looking at the root causes of bullying in addition to just dealing with the immediate effects. There's a ton of information out there. Education sites and journals might be a great place to look. Check out oercommons.org, Education Week, and mea-mft.org. Or it would be easy to arrange to chat with one of the professors in the UM School of Education. A few case study examples could create a powerful pathos appeal.

      Delete
  5. Why is religion necessary? Why do we believe in a higher being? Why do athletes, big name music artists, and famous celebrities thank God for giving them their trophy? Why don't these people give themselves credit? These are the questions I am curious into answering. In my own opinion, religion is present because it gives people a sense of hope, and peace of mind when things go wrong. If your mother dies of cancer at a young age, why would God put that into his plan for her? Religion sparks hatred towards others and sorts out people into groups. Seems as if people do not unite as much if their religion does not match with another's. It baffles me that 8 out of 10 people in America believe that angels exist. It's my understanding that the word 'praying' is nothing short of the word 'hoping.' Why must people judge and vote on a leader of our country solely on that fact if believes in one of the branches of Christianity. It doesn't make sense to me that a Bible of stories has to teach people to have good morals instead of people just already knowing what is right from wrong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is an intriguing issue, but be careful to engage in civil discourse when writing to prevent it from just being an alienating rant. It might be effective to look at a specific case where atheists felt their right to freedom from religion was being infringed upon. Or, there was a bill proposed in the Montana legislature recently that would require the teaching of creationism in schools. That could provide context for writing. It's great to be passionate about this issue -- just make sure that you're also compassionate and smart about it.

      Delete
  6. An issue which is on the 2013 ballot in Montana is a proposition to notify the parents of minors trying to get an abortion. I dont know much about current laws or complications with abortion, but i feel strong enough against the subject to want to write about it. I hope to find out more info on laws and the current status of the issue. Since abortion in general is a large topic, i hope to just focus on this specific referendum or abortion in Montana specifically. Pathos appeals sound like they would work well for this issue, and logos appeals should be effective as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm glad that you're looking at a specific bill rather than making arguments about abortion in general. You're right that abortion is an emotional topic for a lot of people and it's natural that your argument will rely heavily on pathos. Be sure to also research the context and counter argument. How many minors in Montana have abortions without notifying their parents? I suspect this number is very small, and these young women probably have some serious family issues. You'll have to argue then why this law is or isn't necessary.

      Delete
  7. My topic idea is to write about football and the problems in the league with concussions and mostly the rule changes that the NFL is proposing to make the game safer for the players. Some of these rule changes have the potential power to completely change the game and people that have watched the game for a long time are opposed to some of these rule changes. I have done some research and being an NFL fan I have seen some of the new rules in effect and the changes they have made to how the game is played. I have met people that are for the rule changes and some that are against them. I have more of a middle line opinion because in my opinion some of the rules help and some don't, and others need to be changed so they can be better assessed on the field.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like your idea about taking more of a middle-ground position balancing concerns about player safety with preserving the excitement of the game. Be sure to specifically break down which rules seem promising in reducing injuries and which ones seem unecessary. Also a few facts and figures about concussions and their long-term effects could provide background context. Are you planning to interview any of the Griz players or coaches?

      Delete
  8. I am going to write about the debate whether or not to allow public access to the Blackfoot river between the Weigh Station river access site and Milltown state park. I personally believe the river should be cleaned of all the hazards due to the lumber mill and then free access to be allowed. FWP is proposing that the land between the existing water and high water line be open to the public, but the banks above the high water line to remain off limits.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really appreciate that you're writing about a really specific local issue. Unfortunately, I don't have much background information on it, so I have to trust your expertise. I'm sure you know that it'll be important to acknowledge both sides and describe what some consequences might be if it's opened before the hazards are cleaned up. There's a decent chance that one of the local newspapers would be interested in publishing a piece on this topic, so make it good!

      Delete
  9. I havn't chosen a topic yet, so I am going to write about somthing I am mildly interested in to complete this post assignment.
    Gun control. Is it good or bad? Is it worth listening to? Does it realy matter? What is being done? What are the newist proposals? Who will this affect?
    I havn't done a lot of research on this, but I have heard about several public concerns.
    It is stated in the Constitution that we have the right to bear arms. This is not a new fact to anyone who knows our Constitution or who had to take a gov. class in high school. While this is true, may still fear that the gov. will do anything they can to limit the number of guns available to the public. One thing I have heard is that two years ago or so it became very difficult to walk into a sports store and find the right amo for certain rifles and pistols. The theory I heard was that the gov. was atempting to limit the amount of amo available in an atempt to control gun use. The reason this was suposed to be true was because the Constitution says we have the right to own guns, but never sayed we have the righr to unlimited amo....wheather this is true or not I don't know. The idea could have come from someone whith a grudge against the gov. and is big into conspiracy, or it could have some truth in it. One thing is for sure: the gov. has never answared the question (that I know of). Maybe its my topic, maybe not. I am prety sure I will do somthing having to do whith gun control but I don't know what aspect I want to write from. This tid bit was just meant to be funny and odd. I think it is anyway...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember when I was in high school about a million years ago, I watched Chris Rock on a comedy special say the best way to prevent unintended casualities from drive-by shootings would be to make bullets cost $10,000 apiece. That way the shooter would really make each one count. Another ammo-related oddity. If you don't want to write about a specific bill like bringing guns on campus, what would you think about writing about why there are so many conspiracy theories about the government taking people's guns away? Don't hesitate to email me this weekend if you have a sudden breakthrough on a topic you want to write about and want some feedback.

      Delete
  10. My topic right now (tentitively) the the Missoula County Public School's Superintendent's most recent raise.

    My sort of overarching arguable question is, "Should federal and state tax money that feeds into our public schools go to raises of higher officials or to other issues like more teachers and teaching assistants and even new computers.

    Some of the background information that I have is that Montana's public schools are struggling. We are the third worst in the nation as far as money we pay in federal taxes minus federal money that feeds into Montana. As a result, one of the things that suffers as a result of the lack of tax dollars is our schools systems. When teachers retire, often they are not being replaced. Class sizes are growing and support money is going down. I also know that MCPS is currently trying to pass two millevies for technology. This leads the the question "if MCPS is trying to pass milleveies, and obviously need money, why are they giving a 13% raise to the superintendent. What information I hope to find is why this superintendent is a SUPER superintendent and if he actually deserves this raise. Also, if MCPS is doing okay as far as funding.

    Logos: statistics on salaries of the superintendent, principles, teachers and staff. How, in many ways, our education system is failing our students. On an international level, between the 5th and 9th grade, we start to fall far behind on the international level.

    Ethos: I have been a student in Montana for over 10 years, my mother is a School District 2 teacher, and I am an education major so I like to stay informed on issues with the education system.

    Pathos: My mother teaches Kindergarten and has TWENTY FIVE kindergarteners in her class. That is far too many for Kindergarten. Also point out some of the emotional aspects of students right to a good education in America and our tax money should be going towards that!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for including so much. It sounds like you have a really clear idea about what information you want to find and what the best arguments might be. There has been A LOT about this in the Missoulian in the last three or four months. It's worth looking at some of the letters to the editor as well as just the news article; I know a few local educators who've submitted pieces. I think you'll find that Apostle has done some good things. I know he's great at fundraising and encourages new pedagogical innovations, but the questions will be not only if his pay raise is the best use of limited funds but what kind of message it sends. Also, 25 kindergarteners? That sounds like it would be nuts!

      Delete
  11. My topic is the tobacco ban on the UM campus. It really isn't inforced and even if it were, students would still smoke on campus. The only thing that the ban prevents is having the ashtrays around where people will smoke. This leads to a terrible mess in these areas such as the area right in front of Aber Hall. A reasonable solution would be to set up smoking areas with ashtrays and maybe even a small structure for when it is raining or snowing outside so they won't be smoking right up against the buildings. This would help prevent smoke from seeping into the buildings and other students rooms.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a pretty good topic that is really affecting your life right now. Also, since it's very much a campus issue, there might be a possibility of getting it published in the Kaimin, so make it good! It might be helpful to interview someone from the Curry Health Center and look at how other campuses around the country deal with tobacco use.

      Delete
  12. My topic is about performance enhancing drugs in sport. My question is 'should performance enhancing drugs be allowed in sports?' I am taking the side that performance enhancers should be allowed into sports. The reason that PEDs are not allowed in sports is to attempt to keep the playing field even for everyone. However performance enhancers are used widely by athletes in all sports. Sports leagues have tried to increase suspensions and penalties for users of these PED's but stiffer punishments have done little to decrease the number of cheating athletes every year. To truly even the playing field there is only one solution: legalize performance enhancers.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for posting your idea, Henry. You have a pretty unique position on the issue, which definitely will make the paper more interesting than an anti-PED stance. What you're advocating sounds a little crazy though. I can't imagine watching a sport where everyone is super jacked-up on steroids, growth hormones, amphetamines, and whatever else they get shoot into their veins. Wouldn't that be the result of leagues condoning PEDs? You might have to be careful to qualify which drugs and which sports to keep your argument from tumbling down a slippery slope fallacy.

    ReplyDelete