What are some of the ideas in "Gimme Shelter" that intrigued, annoyed, confused, or inspired you? Choose a sentence or two to talk about.
"It starts to seem like their skulls are filled with fireflies, that the next generation is a sleepwalking army of gamers and TV babies."
"I don’t care about where they put their damn commas. I just want them to want to know things."
"Spend $40,000 and the prize at the end of the line is a job, maybe? Higher education feels like a lie."
"But that’s okay. I’m not interested in money. I just want to go to the woods and live deliberately. I want to stand in a field of rye and catch children."
"When you’re a kid, they say you can be anything you want to be. It’s not a lie per se, but then again, we can’t all be astronauts. If everyone were a ballerina, they wouldn’t be special, either."
A couple of discussion questions:
1. Is it the student's fault that she has a hard time coming up with a topic for her research paper? What are a few invention strategies that could help her?
2. Does the essay paint an accurate portrait of Missoula? In what ways are your experiences here different from or similar to the ones described?
3. What do you think about the images that accompany this essay? Do they add meaning or are they just cool to look at?
4. The essay is very scattered. She brings up so many different ideas and issues as she navigates the geography of Missoula and her own mind. Is this ADD or brilliance?
5. Does the writer learn anything about herself? If so, what? If not, does it make the essay less satisfying?
6. If you went out for a cup of coffee or a beer with Molly, what would you want to tell her? What would you want to ask her?
Now, we're all going to become published writers. Skim through some of the comments posted at the end of the article and add your own two cents.
Link: http://missoulanews.bigskypress.com/missoula/gimme-shelter/Content?oid=1673147&showFullText=true
Homework for your conferences:
- Revise one of your sketches into a draft.
- The goal is 1000-1200 words, but if you feel inspired, feel free to make it longer.
- Be sure to include at least three images -- these can be images from the web, photos you took, maps, drawings, or whatever you want. Be creative!
- Bring both sketches and two copies of your draft to the conference. Be prepared to point to places in your draft to talk about (see LPE Conf. checklist).
No comments:
Post a Comment